Rosedale Roadblock!

AGhhhhhhh!!!!!!!
I'm sooo close to finishing Rosedale. I stopped. I counted my stitches. Everything was in order. I made some dopey mistake. I frogged and reknit a few rows. I continued knitting. I stopped. I counted stitches. Where the hell did these 5 extra stitches come from??

On top of my stitch count weirdness, I'm really confused by the pattern at this point. I'm supposed to start binding off stitches for the neck but it's off center so I'm not really clear how this works. Sigh... So damned close.